So, you’re a SME (Small to Medium Enterprise) and you’re trying to grow your business online and have ventured into the realms of social media. But what should your priority be? Which social media application should be the number-one priority for your business and get you the most returns?

In this post I’m not going to discuss the pro’s and con’s of each offering with regards to its SEO benefits in the ever-changing realm of real-time search. I’m looking to explore what platform delivers the most return on investment (mainly an SME’s time), the most bang for your buck!

In some respects this should be a simple answer – Facebook.

Facebook – Greater Flexibility

Currently Facebook has far greater flexibility for promoting your business and, generally speaking average users, the people you want business from, don’t get Twitter.

Case in point, I was seeing one of my clients the other day and began discussing their social media options. I had mentioned Twitter to them a couple of weeks earlier (received blank looks) and thought I would leave it with them to quiz their clients about this new real-time communication tool.

The feedback was not great for Twitter because most of their loyal clients (who are within Twitter’s demographic) said they never used Twitter and did not either understand or see the point. This is not helped by the claims that40% of tweets are mere babble.

Twitter – Fun, but is it Effective?

However I do enjoy Twitter, I truly do. I have learnt many a useful fact throughout my day and even connected with some very forward thinking SMEs. But I can’t help thinking that a lot of the people I’m communicating with, and who are actively using it, are on it for the same reason I am, to eventually generate leads through providing relevant business information i.e. not constantly spamming people with useless narcissistic facts like; “I’m eating a sandwich”, “I’m looking outside, its raining”.

I want to believe Twitter has broken through into mainstream New Zealand and there are a plethora of active users out there consuming my advice and enjoying what small bits of my own personality I include in each 140 character post. But maybe the cold hard truth at the moment is that I’m communicating with the wrong crowd, making the same mistake many media folk do in forgetting about their consumers, their target audience, in light of new “gadgets”.

Twitter does not suit every business out there at the moment, however Facebook has that broader appeal, the broader knowledge of the product with everyday users.

Facebook Responds

Facebook obviously see the value in Twitter though and have made a move to go up against Twitter’s very premise it took from Facebook. Its called Facebook Lite and provides the cut-down version of Facebook. Will this succeed? I hazard a guess Facebook don’t really mind as they are very much ahead of the game in all respects, heck Twitter might have even done them a favour. Pushing them to get out of their plush leather chairs and move social media innovation up a notch!

The New Zealand Digital Market

Does geography and general maturity of the New Zealand digital market play a part in the uptake and usability of Twitter? I think it does and to be honest in three years time when the market matures maybe this post could be rendered useless, stuck in the time capsule that is cyberspace. I’m not advocating that small businesses don’t dabble in Twitter. No. I would encourage setting up a Twitter account as it does have many uses outside of simply posting “what you are doing”. It can help with:

  • Networking.
  • Real-time feedback on what’s being said about your business.
  • Real-time relevant information from sources you choose.
  • Promote products, services, enhancements (if your target market is indeed on Twitter)
  • Promote products, services, enhancements (if your target market is indeed on Twitter)
  • Link creation

Facebook Wins…For Now

But, and this is a big BUT, you have to understand there are only so many hours in a day for a small to medium business owner and unless Facebook or Twitter invent a time machine, or you can afford a small army of social media monkeys, then you need to concentrate your limited time on the social media application that will generate the most results. At this moment in time in New Zealand, its Facebook.

Brought to you by: Soup Digital www.soupdigital.co.nz
Growing small to medium businesses online.

Facebook or Twitter - What is the Priority for SMEs?, 4.5 out of 5 based on 4 ratings

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Comments

  1. Absolutely agree. ‘One size does not fit all’. that every tool must be evaluated well for its fit with marketing. So when Tweet Twins Social Media makes client recommendations we do not necessarily pick the 3 main Social Networking tools.

    Social Media has tools that should be used just like any Media Planning exercise. Back to basics marketing – selecting the right tool, at the right time, for the right market.

    We also help people make sense of Social Media through Tweet Twins Hands on Workshops ‘From Hands Up to Hands On’. So enquire at tweettwins@gmail.com about the next workshop or go to http://www.tweettwins.wordpress.com

    VA:F [1.9.17_1161]
    Rating: 4.5/5 (2 votes cast)
  2. IT Outsourcing says:

    I think I prefer facebook because this is really a bit old and I think this is more user friendly then twitter.

    VA:F [1.9.17_1161]
    Rating: 4.7/5 (3 votes cast)
  3. I am a bit of a ‘twit’ or whatever people that twitter are called.
    I tweet as Kiwicare and as The Pest Advice. But I don’t really get it. As Soup says above, I feel like I am twittering to other people doing the same thing I am and not necessarily my targets.
    However, there have been one or two useful tweets of information I have been able to disseminate. Namely the recent early arrival of cluster flies as a problem was twittered by me and I even wrote an article for How To on the subject. The media picked it up a couple of weeks later and it hit the TV, radio and newspapers.

    So I guess I will continue to be a twit.

    VA:F [1.9.17_1161]
    Rating: 5.0/5 (4 votes cast)
  4. JennyWilmshurst says:

    David, there are ways to be more straetgic with Twitter & Social Media. One thing you can start with are to target your clients on Twitter. There are applications availablbe and so you can target by location, inudstry etc

    VA:F [1.9.17_1161]
    Rating: 3.0/5 (2 votes cast)
  5. Which applications would help me target my clients? I use TweetDeck to tweet.

    VA:F [1.9.17_1161]
    Rating: 5.0/5 (2 votes cast)
  6. Soup Digital says:

    Should we not be asking David who his target market is first and what motivates them in terms of purchasing decisions? Then work forward from here.
    Do these applications have traction in the NZ market or are they applications that work well in more active markets like the US?
    The thing is, there might not actually be any real critical mass within his target market actively using twitter or open to a soft sales pitch.
    I would err on the side of caution when it comes to physical time spent grinding out social media (within certain categories it pays to up social media activity such as travel). All in moderation and track performance, if it is working within your category then look to build on it and become more strategic.
    Independent businesses have to cut through the noise when it comes to social media sometimes. They definitely need to start building their Social Media foundations now (not only to be part of a conversation but build links to your website in real time) so when the market does fully mature in NZ they can take full advantage of it.

    VA:F [1.9.17_1161]
    Rating: 5.0/5 (4 votes cast)